I've used this type of CD binder for about 6 years, and they don't show any wear so far. The binder comes with the CD holder pages, so you don't have to buy them separately. It zips up all the way around, so the CDs are kept neat and clean inside. It's a great way to store CDs, and with the clear sleeves, and separate pages, it's easy to organize them. The handle is handy to pull the binder off of the shelf.
Since I have multiple binders, it would be useful to have a place to slide in a binder number. So far, I've been painting numbers on with white-out, but I think a number slot would be a lot easier.